GetPersonnel

Comparison

AI receptionist vs answering service, compared

Both keep calls out of voicemail. They differ in what the caller gets, what each can actually do on the call, and what happens to the bill in a busy month.

The short version

If your calls are mostly bookings, enquiries and messages, an AI receptionist does them faster and more consistently, at a flat price. If a lot of your calls need real judgement, an upset customer, a complicated sale, anything clinical or legal, you want a person on those. The setup that works for most businesses is AI on the front line, with those calls put through to someone who can deal with them.

Side by side

  • Pick-up. AI answers in one ring, every call, even when a few land at once. A shared operator room puts callers in a queue when it's busy.
  • Knowing your business. The AI is set up for your business alone and answers from that. Operators usually work from a short script card and cover many clients.
  • What happens on the call. Both take messages. The AI also answers questions, books the job with the details you need, and transfers to you.
  • Messages. The AI emails a written summary straight after the call. Operator services vary, and some batch them up.
  • Cost. Ours is a flat monthly plan: $149 with 300 minutes, or $300 with 1,000, inc GST. Operator services commonly charge a base fee plus per call or per minute, so a busy month costs more.
  • Hours. Both can run 24/7. Some operator services charge extra after hours or on public holidays. Ours doesn't.
  • Repeat callers. The AI remembers people who've rung before and what it was about. An operator in a shared room is unlikely to.

What the caller notices

With an operator service the caller hears a ring, sometimes a wait, then someone who asks for their name and number and says they'll pass it on. With Ella the caller hears one ring and then a receptionist who can tell them whether you cover their suburb, book them in for Thursday, and put them through to you if it's urgent. The difference is whether the caller hangs up with something done, or with a promise that someone will get back to them.

Live answering service or AI receptionist?

A live answering service means a real person picks up your calls, usually an operator in a call centre answering for many businesses. Most people looking for one want the same thing: callers talking to someone, not a voicemail recording or a menu telling them to press 1. That's a fair thing to want.

Ella isn't a person. What she shares with a live service is the part callers notice. The call is picked up in one ring and answered in a normal conversation, at any hour, instead of going to a recording. On the call she can often do more than an operator with a script card: answer questions about your business, book the job with the details you need, and put the caller through to you.

If most of your calls are bookings, enquiries and messages, an AI receptionist covers them. If most of them need a person's judgement, a live operator service may suit you better. Either way, ring both and hear the difference before you choose.

Where a person is still better

A trained person is better with someone who's distressed, better at negotiating, and better at reading between the lines on an odd request. That's why Ella can put callers through to you or your team. The aim is simple enough. Nobody reaches voicemail, and the calls that need a human get one.

Hear it

Ring (07) 4802 3301. Ella answers. Ask her something awkward and see how she goes. Then ring whichever operator service you're weighing up and compare the two. After that, have a read about our AI receptionist or the 24/7 answering service.

Questions

Is an AI receptionist cheaper than an answering service?
Usually, at small-business call volumes, because it's a flat monthly price rather than per call. Ours starts at $149 a month with 300 minutes, or $300 with 1,000, inc GST.
Can I use both?
You don't need to. The AI handles the routine calls and transfers the ones that need a person to you or your team.
Is an AI receptionist the same as a live answering service?
Not quite. A live answering service puts a human operator on your calls. An AI receptionist also answers live, in one ring and in a normal conversation, but it isn't a person. Calls that need one can be put through to your mobile or your team in Microsoft Teams.
What if a caller insists on a person?
Ella puts them through to your mobile or your team in Microsoft Teams. If nobody's free, she takes a message and emails it to you.
What happens with a question she wasn't set up for?
She answers from what she knows about your business. If a caller asks something outside that, she takes a message or puts them through to you.

Ring Ella and hear it for yourself.

She answers our line exactly the way she'd answer yours. If it suits, we can usually have yours set up within days.